Join our Mailing List

"On my part, I remain committed to the process of dialogue. It is my firm belief that dialogue and a willingness to look with honesty and clarity at the reality of Tibet can lead us to a viable solution."

A tempest in Tibetan temples

February 11, 2011

Allegations of spying and media manipulation lay bare the divisions in
Tibetan Buddhism and tensions between China and India. Mistrust between
rival Karmapas belies the image of a placid religion.

By Mark Magnier, Los Angeles Times
February 7, 2011, 9:27 p.m.

Reporting from Dharamsala, India —
He's a "living Buddha" with movie-star good looks and an iPod, a
25-year-old who rubs shoulders with Richard Gere and Tom Cruise and is
mentioned as a successor to the Dalai Lama.

Now allegations that he's a Chinese spy, and a money launderer to boot,
have laid bare divisions in the outwardly serene world of Tibetan
Buddhism and longtime tensions between China and India.

There's a lot at stake. The Karmapa is among Tibetan Buddhism's most
revered figures and heads the religion's wealthiest sect, with property
estimated at $1.2 billion worldwide. His appointment was approved by
both Beijing and the Dalai Lama — a rarity — but rivals say he isn't the
legitimate leader.

Tibetan Buddhism's image of placid chanting and sublime meditation
belies a more edgy history, analysts say, replete with religious figures
attacking each other and alliances between monasteries and brutal warlords.

The Dalai Lama heads one sect of Tibetan Buddhism, the so-called yellow
hats, a reference to their headgear, while the Karmapa heads a black-hat

After the 16th Karmapa died in 1981, top lamas split over who should
replace him, resulting in three rivals, significant distrust and a fight
over control of the previously shared Rumtek Monastery in Sikkim.

"We in the West tend to project all our fantasies about mystical
spiritualism onto Tibetan Buddhism," said Erik Curren, author of
"Buddha's Not Smiling: Uncovering Corruption at the Heart of Tibetan
Buddhism Today." "It's really like a civil war. There's lots of acrimony."

Last week, some 2,000 Tibetans trudged down steep mountain roads to the
Gyuto Ramoche Temple, the residence of the Karmapa Ogyen Trinley Dorje,
to show their support for the man at the center of the allegations.

"Long live his holiness Karmapa," monks and worshipers chanted,
fingering prayer beads and holding aloft pictures of him with the Dalai

The allegations, largely unsubstantiated, were widely repeated in major
Hindi- and English-language media here, prompting aides and supporters
to wonder who's fanning the negative publicity.

"There's definitely been a witch hunt," said Kate Saunders, a
spokeswoman for the International Campaign for Tibet. She said that with
the Dalai Lama aging, Karmapa Ogyen Trinley Dorje is someone able to
unify the diverse community.

Some believe Indian security officials may be behind the raids and
publicity, concerned over the sect's many temples along the sensitive
India-China border, keen to boost budgets and influenced by supporters
of a rival Karmapa.

"The Karmapa is definitely not a Chinese spy," said Deki Chungyalpa, an
advisor. "I think Indian officials and the media had a role in spreading
this. It makes the situation a lot more volatile." Followers added that
supporters of a rival Karmapa may be involved.

Rabjam Rikki, private secretary to Karmapa Trinley Thaye Dorje, said
such suggestions were completely unfounded.

The latest incident began Jan. 26 after police discovered $220,000 in a
car at a checkpoint. Under questioning, the driver said it came from the
Karmapa Ogyen Trinley Dorje.

A search of the leader's religious offices then turned up $1.4 million
more in cash, including $165,000 in Chinese currency, fueling media
speculation that the Karmapa was working for Beijing. Under Indian law,
residents can hold $2,000 in foreign currency.

"Misunderstandings and mistakes" happened, the Karmapa told followers
last week, but he expressed faith that the truth would prevail.

Aides said the cash came from foreign devotees and that the money at the
checkpoint was intended for the purchase of land for a new monastery.

Tibetan refugees are not allowed to buy land in India, and buying
through an Indian proxy is also illegal. But aides said they had
repeatedly informed the Indian government of their plans.

"If you go strictly by the rules, yes, but it wasn't done with any bad
intention," said spokesman Karma Topden.

Late last month, Chinese Communist Party official Xu Zhitao said the
Karmapa was not a Chinese spy, although that's done little to settle the

"It's possible this is a deliberate salvo by China to stir up more
controversy," said Robbie Barnett, director of Columbia University's
Modern Tibetan Studies Program, given that many Indian intelligence
officials tend to believe the opposite of what Chinese officials say.
"They must be rubbing their hands with glee."

"There is a lot of tension and politics being played out," said Srikanth
Kondapalli, a China studies professor at New Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru

Some fear the infighting could undermine the larger struggle for more
cultural and religious freedom for Tibetans under Chinese control.

"It really damages our image," said Tenzin Tsundu, an activist with Free

Some analysts said some Westerners have a rosy-eyed view of Tibetan
Buddhism, perhaps a reflection of their disillusionment with Western

"Inter-sect conflicts involving physical violence is nothing new,"
Curren said. "It's just like any religion. It has its share of bad
apples, but that doesn't spoil the whole barrel. The sooner Westerners
realize that, the better."

Anshul Rana of The Times' New Delhi Bureau contributed to this report.
CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665
Developed by plank