Join our Mailing List

"I believe that to meet the challenges of our times, human beings will have to develop a greater sense of universal responsibility. It is the foundation for world peace."

Insecure security

August 13, 2008

These are the most secure Olympics, and the most insecure.
By John Krich
August 11, 2008

All of this isn't a product of tensions over Tibet, of "communism,"
or of post 9/11 Muslim threats

Police on every corner, surveillance cameras everywhere, overpasses
cordoned off, listening devices planted in taxis, sniffing dogs,
metal detectors and new electric fences all around. In three days,
I've already been frisked enough times to feel half the nation is
familiar with the sort of chewing gum sticks crumpled in my front pocket.

Still, this hasn't been enough to prevent Chinese leaders' worst
nightmare: the killing on Day 1 at a popular tourist attraction of an
American CEO and prominent Christian, father-in-law of the current
Olympic volleyball coach and father of a former Olympic athlete who
watched his death by stabbing.

It also hasn't prevented several new items like this, reported with a
familiar twist in Sunday's government-run China Daily: "Chinese
people condemned and protested against five foreigners for fomenting
'Tibetan independence' at Tiananmen Square yesterday noon. The five
were then taken away by Beijing police."

All of this isn't a product of tensions over Tibet, of "communism,"
or of post 9/11 Muslim threats. Anyone who bothers to look at the
core old city of Beijing, or what's left of it, will find a city
distinguished by its high blood-red walls around palaces and centers
of powers, the gigantic gates, thick doors and guarded entries
everywhere. This is actually the most fascinating aspect of Beijing's
design -- a city that gave importance to the exact distance one lived
from the throne of the Forbidden City.

And the Communist era, despite its many campaigns against class
privilege, only increased the importance of access, of "back door"
methods to enter the critical compounds, added to the barriers
between the rulers and ruled, the protected and the unprotected.
Today, as wondrous all-glass office towers rise, they are usually
built back from the street, protected by a traditional courtyard, and
heavily patrolled gates at the front.

Hundreds of mute guards stand vigil all-night along embassy row. Even
China's university students seek knowledge within strictly gated
campuses. Along with paper and gunpowder, the Chinese surely invented
the security guard.

And one would have to be an idiot not to recognize that all this
might prove at odds with the so-called Olympic "dream" of mankind
united in peace. Perhaps I'm a bit spoiled from having attended the
1988 games in Seoul, Korea, where, despite a fragile transition from
dictatorship to democratic rule and huge protests in the street, fans
had plenty of open, accessible areas to swap souvenir pins and stories.

I wandered freely in and around the Athletes Village and it was no
problem waiting to speak with some exiting young Olympians or get
their autographs. Likewise in Los Angeles in 1984, there were few
bans or barriers and the free mingling of people the world over was
far more memorable than any sporting memories (like turning my head
toward a hot dog vendor and missing the infamous fall of distance
runner Mary Decker).

So this time, I figured that I could naively head toward the area
labeled as Beijing's "Olympic Green." But asking the best way to get
to the large space laid out between Bird's Nest Stadium, the "Water
Cube" Aquatic Center and a newly-planted Forest Park, I was summarily
told that the low-grade pass hanging around my neck simply wouldn't get me in.

When I persisted and phoned an official at the larger Main Press
Center, she tried to mollify me by offering to send me a fax listing
all the parks in Beijing where journalists were or were not allowed
to get their feet wet. Was it possible that the village "green"
staging an event for all mankind was reserved solely for VIPs? I had
to see for myself, as my taxi driver started circling in vain around
the area and cursing at the numerous roadblocks that thwarted his route.

With a shrug, he dropped me at a dead end enforced by another line of
soldiers. Crossing the street, I found myself in a large untended
parking lot, separated from the Bird's Nest by the untidy litter and
lumber of unfinished construction, a dozen or so Quonset huts and
high fencing. As the dusk approached, and the Olympic torch blazing
atop the stadium grew fiercer and more tantalizingly close, thousands
of ordinary families came to pose before the landmark.

For an hour or so, I amused myself by taking my own snapshots of
their orgy of snapshots. When I finally got someone to record me for
posterity, he managed to come up with the exact angle to make it look
like the Olympic torch was emerging directly from the top of my head
-- or seemed to show my hair on fire.

At dark, I followed the crowds toward the main entrance to the green,
where sniffing German shepherd dogs drew a large crowd and massive
signs invited "the little and the pregnant" to special entry points
and warned against trying to sneak radioactive materials or
"crossbows" into the stadium. Here, too, a guard confirmed that my
status wasn't high enough to enjoy the various corporate tents
stationed within. In the meantime, it was back to the parking lot for
me. This wasn't the Olympic Green but the Olympic Gray.

Perhaps all Olympics from now will have to be like this, given the
endless terror alerts. For the moment, anyway, the destruction of the
last vestiges of Olympic solidarity didn't seem quite so important as
the shocking stabbing of  Todd Bachman on a balcony of the ancient
Drum Tower, but half a mile from the secured confines from where I am
composing these words.

However, what seems most remarkable about the whole incident is how
efficiently it has been swept under Beijing's rug. As far as I know,
the murder was barely reported on television -- the Beijingers I met
yesterday had certainly not heard about it -- and warranted a small
Page 5 notice in the China Daily, buried behind headlines of China's
first gold medals. The identity of the victim was not revealed and
neither was much about the attacker beyond his name.

It is highly probable that not much else will ever be known, since
authorities delayed reporting the crime until they had entirely
cleaned up the area and sent away all possible police or local
witnesses that Western reporters could have interviewed. Undoubtedly,
one of the government surveillance cameras must have caught the attack.

As for the motives, "random crazy" will have to do for now -- though
every Chinese person to whom I spoke called it a set-up by Muslim
organizations bent on embarrassing China and every Western person
living in China swore that this was but the natural outgrowth of a
relentless anti-Western hysteria tied to the national goal of gaining
more medals than the bullying United States.

A statement that Bachman and his family were wearing nothing to
identify them as Americans seems highly suspect, in a town where
almost everyone has some kind of pass hanging around their necks.

In any case, the police overkill at these Games isn't meant mainly at
protecting foreigners from locals, or locals from a few human rights
crazies. It's to prevent the Chinese people themselves from rising up
to protest that the high walls are here, as they have been for eternity.
CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665
Developed by plank