Join our Mailing List

"I believe that to meet the challenges of our times, human beings will have to develop a greater sense of universal responsibility. It is the foundation for world peace."
<-Back to WTN Archives Experts slam Indian stand on Tibet
Tibetan Flag

World Tibet Network News

Published by the Canada Tibet Committee

Thursday, July 3, 2003

2. Experts slam Indian stand on Tibet

By Ehtashamuddin Khan

New Delhi, July 02, 2003 (Rediff) - A meeting of China experts and activists
in New Delhi on Wednesday slammed India for accepting a part of Tibet as
autonomous Chinese territory, calling it a failure of India's foreign

The meeting was convened to discuss Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee's
visit to China -- its successes and failures.

Strategic affairs expert Brahma Chellaney said: "It is India's first
explicit recognition of the annexation of Tibet by communist China. Our
earlier governments also made concessions, but it is for the first time that
India has stooped so low."

During his six-day visit to China, Vajpayee signed a memorandum of
understanding with China recognising the Tibet Autonomous Region as part of
the territory of the People's Republic of China.

Chellaney said the stand was a clear deviation from India's earlier position
on the issue.

He said the Tibet Autonomous Region is a small part of Tibet, where only a
third of the Tibetan population lives. This area has been officially
recognised by China as Tibet, while four Chinese provinces have annexed
large parts of Tibet. So by using the term 'Tibet Autonomous Region' for the
first time in a legal document, India has accepted China's position.

Chellaney said Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru had signed an agreement with
China in 1954, apparently under tremendous pressure, that said Tibet was an
autonomous 'region' of China. "All successive governments have reiterated
this stand," he said. "But now we have totally changed our views on the
issue. Our policy makers don't understand history and have not learnt from
the past. We are reliving history."
During Vajpayee's visit, an agreement was also signed in which China for the
first time hinted of its acceptance of the Himalayan state of Sikkim as an
integral part of India.

But Chellaney, who was involved in Track II diplomacy with China from 1993
to 1999, said the problem of Sikkim was a non-issue and it was made an issue
simply to make concessions on Tibet. "They [the India government] linked the
Tibet issue with Sikkim, made concessions on Tibet, and returned
emptyhanded," he remarked.

Vijay Kranti, a Tibetologist and editor of the magazine Tibbat Desh, agreed
with Chellaney's views. "Two countries are trying to decide the fate of a
third country," he said. "They have no right to do so. Mentally we have
accepted that the Indo-Tibet border is in fact the Indo-China border. That
is what the Chinese want."

He expressed concern over the decreasing Tibetan population in the Tibetan
areas that have been incorporated into mainland China. "If you go to a place
like Lhasa, you will find just one Tibetan among 10 Chinese," Kranti said.

But Sheshadri Chari, editor of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh magazine
Organiser, chose to differ.

"China is changing and we need to facilitate more people-to-people contact,"
he said. "For the first time, China has recognised Sikkim as part of India.
Is that not a victory? And as far as Tibet is concerned, we have always
maintained that Tibet was part of China. There has been no change in our

Tashi Wangdi, a representative of the Dalai Lama, preferred not to take a
clear stand on Vajpayee's visit. "As India and China come closer, I hope
there would be a solution to the Tibet crisis," he said.

To this, Chellaney said Tibet's government-in-exile that Wangdi represents
cannot speak up against the Indian government as it has taken refuge in

A young Tibetan student stood up as the discussions were on and said: "We
are disappointed by Vajpayeeji's visit. India has said exactly what China

Articles in this Issue:
  1. Vajpayee taken for a ride in Beijing? (TIB)
  2. Experts slam Indian stand on Tibet
  3. Warmer ties? Sino-India border still bothers
  4. 19 Tibetans Arrested in Nepal Handed Over to UNHCR
  5. Temples to Tibet on RSS agenda at crucial meet
  6. US warns of worsening Chinese record on human rights

Other articles this month - WTN Index - Mail the WTN-Editors

CTC National Office 1425 René-Lévesque Blvd West, 3rd Floor, Montréal, Québec, Canada, H3G 1T7
T: (514) 487-0665
Developed by plank